A New Teacher’s Guide to the Teacher Evaluation Process

by Amanda Melsby – updated November 1, 2025

I recall my first teacher evaluation process being filled mostly with confusion and fear. I didn’t understand how the forms worked or how many times I’d be observed, and I was too nervous to ask. The only thing I was sure of was fear – the fear that one bad rating would mean I wouldn’t be invited back the next year.

If you’ve never been evaluated before, the process can feel like walking blindfolded through a maze. In fact, simply understanding how the evaluation process works removes most of the fear. When you know what to expect, when to expect it, and what evaluators are looking for, you can focus on teaching instead of worrying.

In this guide, I’ll walk you through everything that happens during a teacher evaluation: the timeline, the different types of observations, the various evaluation models used by many districts/schools, and what evaluators are really assessing when they visit your classroom.

Jump ahead to:

Teacher Evaluations Serve Two (Sometimes Conflicting) Purposes

The Teacher Evaluation Timeline

Teacher Evaluation Models

What Evaluators Look For

Evaluation Ratings and Next Steps

Understanding the Process Removes Most of the Fear

Teacher Evaluations Serve Two (Sometimes Conflicting) Purposes

The challenge with most teacher evaluation processes lies in their dual purpose. Here’s the dilemma:

Formative Purpose: The evaluation process should provide steady, ongoing feedback to help you improve your teaching practice. Just like formative assessments we give students, it is where you learn, grow, and get better at your craft.

Summative Purpose: Teacher evaluations are also used to determine contract renewal for the following year. This is where your performance rating can impact whether you’re invited back.

Is the evaluation process designed to help you improve or to determine whether you will keep your job?

Unfortunately, the answer is often both.

This tension between improvement and assessment makes it difficult for many teachers to embrace the formative aspects, which is, of course, ironic because that is exactly the part most teachers want and need. Try not to let the summative aspect paralyze you. The evaluators I’ve worked with genuinely want you to succeed. After all, they did hire you. They are not looking for reasons to document failure; they are looking for evidence of growth. Do your best to focus on growth and learning from the process.

Click the image above to download the FREE teacher evaluation checklists

The Teacher Evaluation Timeline: What to Expect From Start to Finish

Each school or district has its unique approach, but most follow a similar structure. Here’s what the evaluation process typically looks like throughout the school year:

Beginning of Year: Introduction to the Evaluation Process

Sometime during the first few weeks of school, you should:

Receive the evaluation model/standards
Get timeline and key dates
Understand the specific school/district criteria

Commentary: This is when you should ask questions. Don’t wait until your first observation to figure out what your evaluator is looking for. Understanding the framework early helps you align your teaching practices with what will be assessed.

Fall: Time for Teacher Goal-Setting

During this time, you will work with your evaluator to:

Create a SMART goal for professional growth (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, Time-bound)
Align your goal with the teaching standards

Commentary: A well-crafted goal gives you a roadmap for improvement and provides focus for your observations and feedback meetings. Your evaluator will reference this goal throughout the year, so choosing something meaningful makes the entire process more valuable to you.

Throughout the Year: Classroom Observations

This is where most of the evaluation happens. You’ll experience:

Formal observations – scheduled and longer
Informal observations – unannounced and shorter

Commentary: Observations aren’t meant to catch you on your worst day. They’re designed to see patterns in your practice over time. One mediocre lesson during an informal observation won’t sink you, but consistent issues with classroom management or lack of student engagement might. This is also why maintaining strong classroom routines matters. When your systems are solid, even an unexpected drop-in is likely to go well.

After Observations: Feedback

Within a few days of each observation, you should have:

Scheduled meetings with your evaluator to review observations
A write-up provided for you to review

Commentary: This is where the formative purpose of evaluation actually happens. The observation itself is just data collection. The feedback meeting is where you learn. Approach these meetings as collaborative conversations rather than “criticism sessions” to get significantly more value from the evaluation process.

End of Year: Final Evaluation and Rating

In late spring, you will have a final evaluation meeting where:

Your evaluator reviews your progress on your goal and your observation data throughout the year
You will receive a final rating (the specific rating scale varies by district—often something like “highly effective,” “effective,” “developing,” or “ineffective”)

Commentary: The overall rating often determines whether you’re recommended for contract renewal. It should also reflect the growth you’ve demonstrated over the year. Most evaluators look for trajectory, not perfection. A teacher who started rough but consistently improved often fares better than someone who stagnated at a mediocre level.

Common Teacher Evaluation Models: What Framework Will You Be Using?

Your school/district likely uses one of three major evaluation frameworks. Understanding which one applies to you helps you know what evaluators are specifically looking for.

The Marzano Teacher Evaluation Model

This framework is built around four domains with 60 specific elements within those domains, making it highly detailed. It’s evidence-based, meaning evaluators look for specific, observable behaviors that research has linked to student achievement.

The four domains are:

- Domain 1: Classroom Strategies and Behaviors
- Domain 2: Planning and Preparing
- Domain 3: Reflecting on Teaching
- Domain 4: Collegiality and Professionalism

The Charlotte Danielson Framework for Teaching

This is one of the most widely used models in the United States. It includes four domains with 22 components within those domains. The framework emphasizes teacher growth and reflective practice.

The four domains are:

- Domain 1: Planning and Preparation
- Domain 2: Classroom Environment
- Domain 3: Instruction
- Domain 4: Professional Responsibilities

State or Provincial Teaching Standards

Many districts build their evaluation systems directly around their state’s teaching standards. These vary significantly by location but are typically structured around core competencies for the teaching profession, adapted to reflect local education priorities.

What Evaluators Look For During Observations

Despite differences in evaluation models, nearly all frameworks assess these core areas.

Classroom Environment and Management

Is your classroom organized and welcoming? Do you have clear routines and procedures? How do you handle disruptions or off-task behavior? Do students feel safe and respected? A positive classroom environment isn’t just about control but rather about creating conditions where all students can learn.

Student Engagement and Participation

Are students actively involved in learning, or are they passive recipients of information? Evaluators notice whether all students participate or just a handful, whether students seem interested in the content, and whether they’re intellectually engaged (thinking, discussing, problem-solving) versus just compliant (quietly completing worksheets).

Lesson Planning and Preparation

Evaluators want to see evidence that you’ve thoughtfully planned your lesson with clear objectives, appropriate materials, and alignment to standards. Even during informal observations, they’re assessing whether your lesson has structure and purpose.

Instructional Delivery and Pedagogy

How do you teach? Do you use a variety of instructional strategies? Are you checking for understanding throughout the lesson? Do students have opportunities to practice and apply what they’re learning? Strong instructional delivery means students are engaged and learning is happening, not just that you’re presenting information.

Assessment Practices and Use of Data

Evaluators look for evidence that you’re monitoring student learning in real time (formative assessment) and using that information to adjust your teaching. This might be as simple as asking questions during a lesson and responding to student answers, or as structured as analyzing exit ticket data to plan the next day’s lesson.

What Happens After Your Evaluation? Understanding Your Rating and Next Steps

At the end of the evaluation cycle, you’ll receive a summative rating. The specific scale varies by district, but most use some version of these levels:

Highly Effective/Distinguished: Consistently demonstrates exemplary teaching practices that significantly impact student learning

Effective/Proficient: Meets standards and expectations for teaching; demonstrates solid professional practice

Developing/In Process: Shows potential but requires additional support and growth in key areas

Ineffective/Unsatisfactory: Does not meet minimum standards for teaching

What Your Rating Means for Your Job

If you receive an “Effective” or higher rating, you’ll typically be recommended for contract renewal and can expect to continue in your position next year.

If you receive a “Developing” rating, your district may place you on an improvement plan (sometimes called a Professional Development Plan or Growth Plan) for the following year. Even if they do not do this, they will be monitoring your growth closely the following year, and you will need to demonstrate significant improvement.

Here’s what most new teachers don’t realize: Evaluators expect you to have rough spots as a beginning teacher. What they’re looking for is whether you’re coachable, whether you implement feedback, and whether you show growth over time.

If You’re Worried About Your Evaluation

If you’re genuinely concerned about how your evaluation is going, the best thing you can do is have honest conversations with your evaluator throughout the year. Don’t wait until the final evaluation meeting to find out you’re struggling.

Ask directly: “Where do I stand? What are my strongest areas and what should I prioritize for growth?” Most administrators appreciate directness and will give you clear guidance if you ask. They’d much rather help you improve mid-year than surprise you with a low rating at the end.

If you do not feel comfortable doing that, talk to your department chair or a mentor teacher. Ask them to observe you or talk through any feedback you have been given by your evaluator.

Understanding the Process Takes Away Most of the Fear

Understanding the dual purposes of an evaluation, the timeline, and identifying your school’s evaluation model should greatly reduce the fear of the unknown.

The next steps? Prepare for your observations, write a strong goal, and make the most of your feedback meetings. Check out this post to walk you through preparing for the evaluation.

Next: Read “How to Prepare for the Teacher Evaluation Process”

Want a step-by-step checklist to track your evaluation preparation? Download our Teacher Evaluation and Classroom Observation Checklist to keep organized throughout your evaluation journey.